Proposed Changes to Streaming Royalty Rates Could Impact Songwriters
Songwriter organizations are advocating for a fundamental overhaul of how streaming services such as Spotify and Apple Music compensate for mechanical royalties in the United States. A new proposal submitted to the U.S. Copyright Royalty Board seeks to replace the current percentage-based system with a fixed payment of $0.003 per stream. This change could significantly alter the revenue landscape for independent songwriters and music publishers from 2028 to 2032.
This proposal is part of the Phonorecords V proceeding, which will establish statutory mechanical royalty rates for interactive streaming services during the five-year period starting January 1, 2028. The outcome of this proceeding is crucial for songwriters across the industry, particularly independent musicians who write, record, and release their own music. Furthermore, it may also influence how streaming companies account for music subscriptions that include audiobooks and other services.
Music Essentials
Fine-tuned items for your review.
The record store.
The proposal has garnered support from a coalition that includes the Songwriters Guild of America, Society of Composers & Lyricists, Music Creators North America, Word Collections, Eight Mile Music Companies, the Music Artists Coalition, and independent songwriter George Johnson. Notably, Bernie Taupin, the longtime collaborator of Elton John, has also submitted testimony in favor of the proposed framework.
Under the new plan, streaming services would pay a statutory mechanical royalty of $0.003 for each qualifying interactive stream or limited download in 2028, with annual increases based on inflation through 2032. This proposed rate would apply uniformly across all subscription tiers, including ad-supported services, contrasting with the complexity of the current system.
Currently, the mechanical royalty system is based on a formula that incorporates service revenue, minimum payments, and in some cases, amounts paid to record labels. This results in a complicated calculation that can vary depending on the type of subscription offered. For example, the Phonorecords IV settlement, which governs the period from 2023 to 2027, stipulates that the headline royalty rate will increase to 15.35% of applicable U.S. streaming service revenue by 2027. However, this percentage is only part of the overall calculation, making it challenging for songwriters to predict their earnings accurately.
Proposed Simplifications for Songwriter Royalties
Supporters of the new proposal argue that a fixed per-stream mechanical rate would simplify the system and protect songwriter compensation from fluctuations in subscription structures. One major concern with the current system is the treatment of subscription bundles. In March 2024, Spotify began bundling certain Premium subscriptions with audiobook listening, which has implications for how mechanical royalties are calculated. The National Music Publishers’ Association has estimated that Spotify’s bundling practices could cost publishers over $3.1 billion through 2032 if the arrangements remain unchanged.
The proposed $0.003 rate would mean that a song generating 100,000 qualifying U.S. streams would yield $300 in mechanical royalties for its underlying composition, while one million streams would generate $3,000. However, these figures do not account for the division among songwriters, publishers, and other parties entitled to a share of the composition income. Additionally, the proposal applies only to qualifying uses covered by U.S. statutory mechanical licensing rules, and does not set a global rate for all streaming platforms.
While the proposal has received backing from several prominent songwriter advocates, the streaming services have not publicly endorsed it. The Digital Media Association, representing major companies like Spotify and Apple Music, responded to the proposal by highlighting growth in the U.S. music publishing market, noting that revenue increased from $5.6 billion in 2022 to $7.3 billion in 2025, a gain of over 30%. However, this does not address how those earnings are distributed among individual songwriters.
Artist Spotlights
The Phonorecords V proceeding is particularly relevant for independent musicians who retain control of their publishing rights, as changes to mechanical royalty rates could directly impact their income. A fixed per-stream rate could simplify revenue forecasting, allowing artists to estimate their mechanical royalties more easily. However, it is important to note that a higher statutory rate does not guarantee that every songwriter will receive the compensation owed to them.
As the Copyright Royalty Board reviews the evidence and arguments submitted by various parties, the outcome of this proceeding remains uncertain. The proposed changes to streaming royalty rates could reshape the financial landscape for songwriters, particularly those who are independent and self-releasing their music. The debate surrounding the $0.003 proposal highlights the need for a clearer and fairer system for compensating songwriters in the evolving music industry.




